Here are some pictures of the problem, as illuminated by sawnami's reference to the parkinlube parts list for the starter.
[/a]This shows the wear inside the cup, I wondered why other guys would
be looking for replacement for a worn out cup, now I know.
Here are the dogs in the relaxed, retracted position.
Here they are extended in the 1 and 7 o'clock positions. The other ends
of the dogs are actually retracted from their rest position. The dog assembly
can be seen clearly in the ipl on parkinlube. The little springs pull the dogs in,
friction with the stationary center post and the washer on top marked 375-37L
holds the assembly back when the rope pulley rotates to begin the start cycle.
The cage and dogs are rotated by the pulley but there is enough play to allow
the dogs to be pushed out to contact the cup. I think they could have put
some teeth on the inside of the cup but then they would not have sold as
many cup replacements, eh?
The dogs work correctly by sliding out under friction with the center post of
the starter when the rope is pulled. That part is fine, although lubing the
friction washers was a bad idea, the design seems to be robust enough in
that area to resist the occasional drip of oil.
The "rub" is in the sharp edge needed to engage the cup. The light colored area
on the left of the dog face is worn flat, or rather curved to match the inner
curve of the cup. I figured there would be enough friction there with the dogs
getting cammed out and moving at an angle. Not so, the cup shows wear
from slippage, I suppose if the dogs were sharp enough that area of the cup
would develope teeth and there would be no slippage. Perhaps the original
inner face of the cup was serrated, no way to tell from this example.
I will pull the dogs out and sharpen them so they dig in, then we will see what
the prospects are of this old beast making some chips again. Right now I
have to get ready to entertain the granddaughter, she is bringing her parents
to dinner.
Thanks for your help, it really makes this old saw BS fun,
Dan